The Babylonians did not use abstract variables like we do today. Instead, they asked questions about specific quantities, such as length, area, or volume. Modern mathematical symbols were not used, and their notation was more like written language.
The article emphasizes that the Babylonians were able to solve complex mathematical problems without using the abstractions we use today. Their approaches were practical and based on actual issues, indicating that while abstraction helps modern mathematics, it is not the only strategy for solving mathematical problems.
For number theory, we can explore properties of numbers by listing the numbers and finding the patterns and sequences.
Revised:
Babylonian Algebra:
Babylonian mathematics was highly practical, focusing on specific problems rather than general formulas. They dealt with concrete quantities like lengths, areas, and volumes directly.
Problems were often stated as word problems. They used tables of values to aid in calculations, such as tables for multiplication.
Instead of variables like x and y, Babylonians described problems using everyday language, referring to specific quantities and objects.
Many algebraic problems were solved geometrically. For example, solving a quadratic equation was approached by manipulating areas and lengths in a geometric context.
General Mathematical Principles Before Algebra
Before the development of algebra, many mathematical concepts were expressed through geometry. For example, the Pythagoreans used geometric diagrams to represent and explore numerical relationships.
Tables were a common tool for calculation. For instance, multiplication tables helped in performing complex calculations without the need for general formulas.
Problems and their solutions were often described verbally, using everyday language. This method was more narrative and less symbolic.
Mathematical principles were often taught and understood through practical examples and real-world applications, rather than abstract theory.
Stating General or Abstract Relationships Without Algebra:
Number Theory: Instead of using variables and equations, patterns and properties of numbers could be explored through listing and visually examining sequences of numbers, much like the way prime numbers or perfect numbers were identified.
Geometry: Geometric shapes and figures can represent mathematical concepts. For example, the concept of the Pythagorean theorem can be demonstrated using a diagram of a right triangle with squares on its sides.
Calculus: The fundamental ideas of calculus, like limits and rates of change, could be explored through geometric slopes and areas under curves.
In summary, while modern algebra provides a powerful and efficient language for expressing and solving a wide range of mathematical problems, historical approaches demonstrate that it's possible to explore and convey complex mathematical ideas through more concrete and practical means. The Babylonians, for instance, effectively handled what we now recognize as algebraic problems, but they did so using specific, real-world scenarios and a more narrative style, without the abstract symbolism that characterizes modern algebra.
Thanks Sally. I would like you to elaborate a bit more on this. How was Babylonian algebra different from the algebra we are used to? (Would you even call it algebra?) Can you give an example that clarifies the differences between modern day algebra and Babylonian 'algebra'?
ReplyDeleteOK, thanks for this revision!
ReplyDelete